"Spare the rod, Spoil the child"?
Question: Which category do you fall into ?
i Never spank
ii Pro-spanking
iii Wish we have not spanked
Or do you hold a different view?
Answers:
PRO-SPANKING
I use every consequence contained by the book, I hold nothing support, that includes spanking. By tactics close to time-outs, grounding, and multiple warnings kaput, my children have chosen spanking for me, I of late follow through.
SPANK SPANK SPANK ALL THE WAY!
There is a MAJOR difference between spanking and beating! Also main difference between spanking and abuse!
i did spank,but not anymore i found other ways to discipline my children,im not against it,but in attendance are other ways.
wish we have not spanked. Anytime that I have spanked my kids , it is because I own lost my temper. It is circuitously proportional to the mischievous act.
i be spanked, at the time i wish i hadn't be spanked, but now i am grateful that i get spanked because it has made a better personage out of me. And i plan on using that form of discipline on my future children.
spanking on the bottom...is ok contained by my eyes...until they reach a particular age. Slapping the hands is ok.until a enduring age. Doing something like...they bit and you bite them for it...is ok within my eyes...as long as it isnt real complex. Once they reach a particular age...it need to shift to taking privilages away and such. Im pro-spankng as long as it isnt to tricky...you are using an open foot and you dont use any foreign objects.
I do spank my child but that is the concluding resort.
Never spank. There are other ways of disciplining a child than by physical force.
My grandmother spanked--my mother spanked--I spanked--and now my daughter spanks. (her 3 year old-fashioned daughter) We all hold had respect and discipline. None surrounded by my family own depression and we all own lots of love.
My experiences in life span.
i have spanked my kids and see here is nothing wrong beside spanking if there are rules to it
We enjoy never spanked our child-our view is that belligerence is violence no event what,you're only tutoring a child that if they get frustrated & can't solve a problem by using their brains consequently resorting to violence is the answer!! Our child is 16 very soon and is well behave,polite,considerate etc..and we created/moulded her into that type of person in need resorting to spanking her.It is a lazy parenting method.
AS A SINGLE PARENT,MY SON WAS SPANKED WHEN IT CALLED FOR IT.MY MAIN RULE WAS TO GO TO HIS ROOM,SIT ON HIS BED AND THINK ABOUT WHAT HE DID.NO TOYS,BOOKS,ETC.HE AND I WOULD TALK ABOUT WAHT HE DID AND I ALWAYS TOLD HIM I LOVED HIM.HE'S 22 NOW AND STILL TELLS ME WHAT A GOOD JOB I DID RAISING HIM.
When I be young, I be spanked and sometimes a little bit more (kicked). This single happened if I be being rude or disrespectful. I turned out ok anyway. It a moment ago helped me realize what be right and wrong. I will probably spank my kids when I have them but I come up with I'll spare the foot. My brothers and I were other so scared when Dad kicked us. So yeah. I'm pro spanking as long as it's a short time ago spanking and doesn't go any farther.
I would prefer the be sneaky
Ie if boy is doomed to failure send surrounded by mum into school to humiliate him.
If kid doing something unsafe show them exactly what the dangers involve.
ie play near fire spend time in burns ward
I rebel any spankin to parent to put their hand on their heart and speak about us that they were surrounded by control of themselves 100% everytime they raised their hand to their children. I was spanked and I know it be becuase my dad lost his temper and lost control. I own spanked my son and immedietly regretted it as I was angry.
There are so tons other more effectived ways of discipline. Do you hit your partner becuase you don't agree with them or they aren't acting exaclty as you would resembling? Do you hit the lady surrounded by the shop because she is going to slow for your liking?
I hope the answer is no. Don't you meditate your childrem decerve that same level of resepct?
And I fall through to see how biting a child who has bitten you is going to initiate them that is wrong!!
Treat others how you would decision to be treated yourself.
Why would you teach a child that hitting someone (calling it spanking is only pandering to your own sensitivity) is okay, as long as it's within particular rules (as one earlier poster said)?!
I be spanked, and remember very clearly the hurt & humilitation I feel. It did not make me surmise about what I'd done, within fact it made me displace the remorse I should've be feeling for anything it was I have done wrong with anger towards my mother for hitting me.
never spank
Never spank.
I've see too many cases where on earth the spanking escalates to beatings. Once a parent get into that mindset, and the child continues to misbehave, as they usually do, either out of retaliation or because of a desperate inevitability for physical affection in any form, they tend to adopt the attitude that the child misbehaves because he wasn't whitewashed long enough, knotty enough or commonly enough, never that the punishment newly isn't appropriate.
Better not to start.
Speak roughly to your little boy,
And beat him when he sneezes:
He solitary does it to annoy,
Because he knows it tease.
Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, Chapter 6.
Lewis Carroll
i dont hold children but if i thought that it would need disciplining next i would, as long as you didnt over do it.
never did me any harm.
Pro-spanking.
I would other try and deal beside things verbally but if a spank be needed then i would.
As others enjoy rightly said there is a BIG difference between a spank and a hiding.
If we in the UK have more back-up from law to spank our kids when leery or out of stripe we wouldn't have some of the loud unruly hooligans that plague our school and towns. And if teachers have more control we wouldn't have adjectives this diabolical behaviour at conservatory...
i was spanked, and as all the same i can't see that it has done me any impair but i don't think i would spank my children. (havn't get any yet), but after everything i know about spanking/smacking, everything i own learnt, i wouldn't do it.
Pro-spanking and hitting as long as you don't snuff the kid, spank a kid 1 year and under and don't break any bones.
I repugnance getting spankings but I usually deserve it so I guess I am pro spanking
I smacked my daughter on the hand when she be very small if she be sticking it into an electric socket or something but as she got elder I used to count to three and if I got to three she would be punished, I never get to three as the tone in my voice would caution her never to push it that far. Now she's a teenager I threaten to steal away her MSN or mobile phone, a fate worse than annihilation for her!!
Pro.
I want my children to grow up with dicipline. Not shift off the rail as I have see around here where parent cannot/will not disipline their kids.
That said, just do so when it warrants that sort of punishment.
2. as a child i be only smacked for doing something really wrong, save for that a clearing of my dad's throat, or being watch over the top of the galsses was satisfactory. Smacking done properly is not a problem, however in excess it is wrong
My 2 be born in the precipitate seventies, I never had to smack massively much. WHY? Because they knew I would.
Never spank, it's 2007 not 1917!!
I used to be a hanger-on of spanking. Back when I had no children but know everything there is nearly raising them.
Now that I in reality have kids, I am of a strange persuasion. I prefer methods of punishment that involve explanations of consequences and my child's interaction in explaining to me what be done wrong, why it was wrong and how it could enjoy been done better. I find it much more powerful when my child has a full compassionate of what happened and what choices they have a choice from the beginning. Getting them to devise of other things they could have done give me the opportunity to discuss alternate consequences as well which help my children know how to think things through formerly they act. Any one who tell me my kids don’t understand, are purely plain wrong. Most kids deserve a lot more credit than they are given. There is a difference surrounded by fear and respect. I want my children to do the right entry because they know it is the right thing. I want them to conform me because they trust and respect me. I think explicitly quite a bit different than not doing the wrong piece because they are afraid of me. I know I'm bigger and stronger than they are. I don't need to prove it. I suppose that resorting to spanking shows a lack of moderation to take the time, as economically as, a lack of cleverness to have a sneaking suspicion that of any non-violent alternatives. The turning point for me was when I realize, my children are not my possessions, they are people. Society say that if your child throws a fit in the store, you are a discouraging parent that doesn’t know how to properly discipline them. I say, children will tryout the boundaries, not because they have desperate parents, but because they are human. If you really think something like it, you as an adult are not that different. Tell me you don’t push the speed shorten. You’ll do it till you get caught, later you’ll do it again. Perhaps we should adopt flogging as punishment for speeding?
I am definitely not against spanking. It is however a ultimate resort. I found a VERY good timeout method that works close to a charm!! (on all 3 of my kids)
in attendance is diff. between spanking and beating .
More Questions and Answers...